recovering_fan wrote:
This is a classic patriarchal bait-and-switch by the NFL: "Come back and worship me, baby, and I won't hit you any more!"
[FYI, British readers, the "NFL" = the National Football League. That's American football, of course.]
--RF
Not to rant, but I am going to elaborate on what I meant here. (I hope the life-long anti-sports people at this site will forgive any sports jargon. It's not a "meme" or anything like that. But I am going to talk about football and a little basketball. Not much, though.)
First, let me say that while I was sports fan I admired Drew Brees. My cynical comments were not about him. While I was still a fan, I enjoyed following his progress in football. I started off my relationship with him by smirking dismissively at him from afar during his playing career with San Diego, during the early part of last decade. A lot of people told me that he was not that good, and since I am no expect on football, I believed the pundits. Then he turned up on "Sports Science", where they talk about the physics of sports, and I was astounded at the accuracy with which he threw a football. Then he won the Super Bowl with the Saints, and I felt genuinely glad for him. He seemed very modest in his interviews, too. I guess getting replaced by Philip Rivers in San Diego and watching your career almost end will give you a sense of perspective that stays with you when you take your place among the game's best.
But when the women and the feminist men who watch
Ellen tell me that a few remarks of his somehow rehabilitate sports as an institution suitable to provide American boys with "legitimate role models" I have to scoff at the idea. In the months before Brees appeared on
Ellen and made those anti-bullying statements which have earned him the ardor of some in this forum, there was some very different stuff unfolding on America's premier sports network, ESPN. In March, when a bunch of (relatively) nerdy guys from Cornell University surprisingly defeated some teams in the college basketball tournament, Colin Cowherd held forth on his
SportsNation comedy show for about five minutes on how little respect he had for nerds and how all women despised nerds. He saw fit to differentiate between nerds (people who did things like memorize pi and assemble computers) and smart people (who did things like practice law or appear on sports entertainment shows). Then, in June or July, one first-year NFL player named Dez Bryant foolishly refused to carry pads for some of the veteran players, and ESPN commentators showed the whole world what happens to NFL players when they don't fall in and serve their elders. (There was footage of players getting tied to goalposts, basically. Just your standard low-grade hazing.)
Anyway, it seems to me like the NFL and sports in general are sending us mixed messages. Boys watch ESPN, and their mothers watch
Ellen. And while boys are watching footage of players tying each other to goalposts to break each others' will, mothers are listening to Brees talk about respecting diversity. It's good cop, bad cop. Bait the mothers with Drew Brees's charm; switch to low-grade hazing when the boys are watching.
If Brees had appeared on Colin Cowherd's
SportsNation and told Cowherd that, contrary to Cowherd's own opinion, nerds ought to be treated with respect, I might have been impressed by that. (Don't do it, Drew. It's not worth the aggravation!) But did his words on a show like
Ellen really send a message to American boys? No, it's just
Ellen, so who cares? It only counts if you say it on ESPN!
--recovering_fan
PS--The only athletes I consider role models are the ones who tell us they are not. There are such athletes, and I like them.